Enter your idea

You should have the 2 options either just 'Approve' or 'Approve & Email' not every user needs the same thing.

Do better Xero!!

I have 4 Ladies working in our office and complicated Invoicing requirements.
It will be so easy for them to accidently "Approve and Send" instead of leaving for the manager to check again (which is BEST PRACTICE) before sending to a large, inflexible customer whose system will not allow amendments after receipt.
This is "Book Keeping 101" Xero for heavens sake.

Draft status - rolling Invoices as yet unfinished.
Approved - Completed but requires checking by Supervisor/manager prior to sending.
Sent - checked by Supervisor as correct and sent

Really hoping the default button will revert to just 'approve' with the new invoicing. With so many invoices to enter on a daily basis, this will make it a lot more efficient for our business. Frustration arises when extra steps are unneccessarily added to what is a seamless process currently with the classic invoicing.

That's lazy programming - as if they can't allow users to apply their own default settings - any IT expert worth their salt could add the relevant coding surely?

What happens if you find a mistake after you have approved, that you need to correct, but now the email has already been sent? Now you get to look like a moron in having to contact the customers, tell them to ignore the invoice and then correct and send another... all because Xero decided, via questionable arbitration, that it was a good idea to do 2 functions with the click of one button.

Sorry, but this is a dumb decision.

Default should be Approve.

Better yet, let us select our own defaults and not be dictated to by a majority of a minority of selected beta tester users.

We do prefer the ‘Approve’ button as a default.

I experimented with ‘Approve & Email’. When you click it, it gives you an option to cancel it. The invoice is approved, but not emailed. It is not ideal, as it requires two clicks instead of one. But who knows when Xero can fix this issue? Meanwhile, we can use these two clicks to approve invoices without using the dropdown menu.

No doubt the majority is what Xero thinks it is. Maybe suitable for ones who invoice on the go and don't have to worry about other issues and can send straight away.
This should never have been set as the default, once again Xero decide how we use things. If they can change it to this then they should be able to easily set up how it was originally or allow the user to set their own default. I don't even approve and send invoices straight away and I imagine this is going to cause a lot of issues for one of my clients when its forced on them, as they are in the Travel Industry so need to double check invoices before they are even sent out as sometimes there are changes needed to the invoice after it's generated.

XERO AREN'T LISTENEING TO THEIR USERS - MAYBE IT WORKS FOR THEM BUT NOT EVERYONE OPERATES THE SAME WAY SO STOP FORCING THINGS ON YOUR USERS THAT AREN'T PRACTICAL.

I would like to query what sort of test group the "majority" of your customers actually came from ?
Whilst this feature might be slightly more convenient for those who invoice directly in Xero there would no doubt be a significant proportion of users who integrate third party platforms and stock control systems to generate invoices and use Xero for accounting only.

We cannot have customers re-sent an invoice every time we approve it !! Having to choose from a drop down to prevent this is adding yet more needless time to process through invoices.

If a default cannot be chosen by the user why not simply provide two separate buttons to be clicked, one to Approve, one to Email ? I don't think the UX would be considerably impacted by this. Please re-consider this decision.

Absolutely businesses should be given the option to set their default preference for such a thing— it affects workflow so much! At the bare minimum, it should be a standard approve button with options to change action as it has been. If Xero wanted ultimately happy users, though, they’d let them be able to pick what works best for themselves with an option in the organization settings. I personally have always wanted “Approve and Add Another” as default, but I’ve never assumed every other user would want it that way. Let us pick our defaults, please

Just how many is 'majority'?

I was just told by support that they will not be changing the button to "Approve". Why not make it an option for users to save their own default setting? I have not read one comment on any Xero forum where the user prefers the "Approve & Email" button.

This is going to create a lot of headaches for me and my staff.

Xero has basically said "no" in one of the other threads.

https://productideas.xero.com/forums/939198-for-small-businesses/suggestions/45438514-new-invoicing-select-default-for-approve-butto

When working with invoices and/or draft invoices, it would be super helpful if we can customize which "enter" option we'd prefer on top. So instead of "save and close" we can choose "save and add another" or "Approve and Email" we can choose "approve and View next" for draft invoices, etc. Preferably, it would be an option we can choose and apply based on invoice template (so different clients can have different defaults based on their needs/invoicing frequency). It would improve our speed with processing multiple invoices or bulk uploaded ones.

Approve and email should NOT be the default. This is going to create so many errors for my small business. Patients will get invoices that says they need to pay even though they have paid at the time. Users are consistently complaining about this and it needs to be fixed.

I submitted a support ticket and was told "Approve" would be the default due to so much backlash. There are only 2 weeks until the new invoicing is defaulted, and this has not been fixed.

I also never approve and email straight away as sometimes these get sent to another person first for review so SHOULD NOT BE THE DEFAULT. Stupid that they set that option as the default when it wasn't the option in classic.

They don't care what their users are saying judging by Kelly's comment above. They should have migrated everything from classic across then looked at adding options to that not change everything when moving over.
It is horrible to use and I dread having to use it when classic is no longer available.
So many requests have been put forward over the years and they ignore those and just do what they want because maybe there haven't been enough votes for a suggestion, or they turn off the ability to vote. Gone down hill and continuing to go downhill from what I see yet put their prices up but offer big discounts to new users and never mind long term users. Seems we're paying to cover the difference.

I agree with many of the comments below - I never email invoices and having a default of just "approve" used to be possible and having to go to the drop down list every time is really irritating! Surely a value could be added to the invoice settings panel to allow users to select what is the default action of this button?

Yes Yes Yes, I need this option. Most invoices I add to xero do not need to be emailed. So I would normally just approve or approve and print. Please bring this back or add a feature that will allow us to change the setting.

Please reconsider making this an option a user can set for a default that suits their workflow. While I'm sure Xero's own accounts staff wanted this for their monthly invoicing process, many many other businesses have a workflow for which 'Approve and Email' is potentially harmful to their brand. Digging in your heels on this one is harmful to *your* brand.

Absolutely doing my head in also. Why assume what we want? Give us the option!

Quickbooks has had this function for quite some time. Quickbooks these days is seeming more and more attractive, not least because talking to anyone at Xero is like hitting your head against a wall.

This whole new invoicing has been a shambles, adding in features that, as far as I can tell, no one was asking for, and in doing so ruining what was a perfectly good invoicing screen.

Xero, in case you haven't picked up, i'm an increasingly unhappy customer.

This is doing my head in too.

Some times I prepare invoices overnight but do not want to send them out until after lunch the next day. Example, I may work at night and finish doing invoices at say 11pm. I do not want my client to wake up and the first email of their day is an invoice from my firm. I would rather send it through after lunch that day.

Very stressful.

Additionally, given you were able to run both invoices systems, why the mandatory forcing of users onto the new system. Why not let us continue to be able to use the old system...?

Incredibly frustrated.